Been on a wallet hunt for years... so have you, right S.P.? The wallet that J. Lo. gave me about 8 years ago has served me very well, but is on its last legs. Generally I prefer a smaller wallet, but more than a bifold or pouch, so it's a tough find... Here are some nice ones that I've come across. Most have been injected with the bit of fun too! The Proenza Schouler at the bottom is my fave of this list.
'Hue Pop Wallet' (love the combo!)